Cardio vs Resistance training: Which is more helpful for your mental well-being and why?

We’ve all heard about just how important exercise is not only for your physical health, but also (and far more significantly), how important it is for your own sense of mental well being. Yet just what type of exercise is the best, natural remedy against mental illness and all of its negative affects?

Before I get into the details of this entry lets take a look at some of the reasons as to why exercise can be helpful in combating anxiety and depression:

download (5)
Endorphins at work!

So without a shadow of a doubt, by forcing yourself to do some form of physical activity on a regular basis, you are doing yourself, and your mind the world of good!

Which form of exercise, and with what intensity, is the best for you and your specific mental needs?

Does an uncompromising weight resistance session that pushes you to your limits meet your desire for contentment? Or does a meandering swim around the pool do more for your peace of mind? Alternatively a gentle, mindful jog around your local neighbourhood might sound the most appealing to you.

The truth is there is no single exercise, whether it is strength or cardiovascular focused, that suits every person out there. It all comes down to not only how much stress you endure on a daily basis but also what kind of activities bring you the most clarity and sense of inner peace.

So without further ado, lets begin with the benefits of…

Aerobic exercise

For those who may be new to/struggle with partaking in regular exercise, and want something on a mild to moderate scale of intensity, this may be the best option for you. By going for a slow paced run for about 5-10 minutes for instance, you can do something that doesn’t require you to gasp for breath and have sweat pour down your forehead while still getting the benefits of the activity. Some psychologists even suggest that a 10-minute walk may be just as good as a 45-minute workout!

In fact moderate exercise is advantageous in that you can keep in shape without fatiguing yourself  – you do not need an athlete’s physique or their gruelling workout schedule to get the mental benefits that come with this form of exercise!

download (4)
A gentle sprint can do you the world of good!

And this is only the short term reward! From running to hiking to gardening to dancing, these are all activities which can be carried out in a natural environment, where you can feel the wind brush against your face and hear the birds sing to each other in the trees.

While it is not imperative that you do cardiovascular activities outside,clinical psychologist Ben Michaelis makes the claim that ‘decaying trees can help reduce anxiety because these plants emit chemicals to slow down the process of their decay,’ not to mention that being around the natural world has been proven to have a calming affect on the mind.

5534221505_c38209dc48_b
Imagine going for a run in a scenic environment such as this!

Additionally, a recent study has suggested that after a period of about 6 months, aerobically fit adults will have received advantages in several ways when it comes to their overall sense of contentment.On a scientific level, doing anything aerobic in nature increases the blood-flow and oxygen to the brain – this physiologic reactivity has positive effects on the several regions of the organ in question.  This includes the ‘limbic system, which controls motivation and mood; the amygdala, which generates fear in response to stress; and the hippocampus, which plays an important part in memory formation as well as in mood and motivation’.

While there is some debate going on as to whether aerobic exercise is just as, if not more beneficial for recipients than antidepressants, ( that is for a whole other article!) there is no doubt that it does the world of good for you, cognitively speaking.

However, what does the scientific community have to say about…

Strength training?

weight-lifting-1161875_960_720
Is lifting weights really all that therapeutic?

Unfortunately the answer is not as satisfactory as would be desired.

This is because researchers have had ‘difficulty finding a lot of high quality research on strength training alone for mental health issues’ which they believe is the result of most studies on mental health and exercise using ‘ general exercise’ – a term which is usually reserved for moderate intensity cardio. Strength training has been neglected as a result.

This is partly down to the difficulties of animal testing when it comes getting rodents to perform any form of strength training– aerobic exercise is as simple as restricting or allowing a running wheel for the rodent to use. Yet trying to come up with a method to enable them to carry weights without causing unnecessary harm to said animal is a little more tricky!

4182287774_33be117443_b.jpg
Animal testing is a complex situation when the question of ethics comes into the equation

However, there is evidence to support that, in some areas at least, putting your all into lifting those weights at the gym has similar advantageous effects to doing cardio. Firstly there is the simple fact that, for some people, myself included, pushing themselves to a fatigued state brings them more of a sense of clarity than a moderate run around the park would do.

Most significantly however, the one aspect where it does seem to be equal or superior to aerobic training is in one respect – improved memory. Seven randomized controlled studies showed that when older adults( a demographic of society who are at risk of having a failing memory) performed resistance training  over a determined period of time, they received positive effects on their ability to perform memory related tasks as a result.

Yet it must be noted that, in a study that compared the two types of exercises, doing weight training ‘only slightly improved the mental well being of people with an anxiety disorder’. The same article also asserts that strength training alone has low to moderate effects on cognition in older adults. Unfortunately, the same cannot be affirmed in the case of depression. The same report conducted 18 training studies examining the effect resistance training in persons with symptoms of depression – it had mixed results to say the least. Some people received a positive effect from it and others did not.

As the report itself summarises pretty adequately, there is a ‘complex network of neurophysiological adaptations that occur with resistance training participation that directly and indirectly effect mental processes’ ; this explains the mixed success rates in strength training’s effect on an individuals mental well being.

There is also an intriguing perspective that strength training is something that should come to us naturally, as it did many years ago, before modern technology came along and made our lives a lot easier. Back then we did not have the option to be idle – we had to be physically f in order to survive!  Is this a solid argument or the outdated conjectures of someone whose mind is stuck in the past? I’ll let you decide on that one!

Interestingly, this all culminates into the question of whether the whether strength training is effective on those who actually know why they are depressed, as picked up on in this insightful article.

So which form of exercise is better?

Now I do not claim myself to be an expert, but it is clear from the evidence above that while weight training has its benefits, it is aerobic exercise that has the slight edge when it comes to being advantageous towards someones mental well being. Even if the competition is not completely fair due to the lack of scientific evidence of the former.

All else failing you could combine aerobic and resistance exercise via circuit training -in this way, you get the best of both worlds!

779319757_d021708e10_z
The best of both worlds?

Remember, as with the case with any mental disorder, it is wise to set yourself small, achievable goals and build up from there! The last thing you want is to fall at the first hurdle – its a common theme amongst us neurotics. We know deep down what we’re capable of and so we aim high, forgetting that while this is an admirable mindset to have, failure can suck us back into that vicious cycle of self loathing and despondency!

Don’t let depression win! Get fit – but do so at your pace!

To end this entry, I leave you with this quote from Michaelis, which affirms that no matter what form of exercise you choose , whether it be aerobic or resistance training or both , you are very likely to benefit from it in the long run :

‘The body is the mind and the mind is the body. When you take care of yourself, you are helping the whole system’

alive-927076_960_720
Inner peace is possible!

What kind of exercise do you prefer? Do you lean towards strength or cardiovascular training? Or perhaps, like me, you prefer to intertwine the two. Whatever your view, feel free to leave a comment below. Let others know of not only what works for you, but of  your ideas and approach towards training your body and mind in general!

 

20 thoughts on “Cardio vs Resistance training: Which is more helpful for your mental well-being and why?

  1. Thanks for this post, it was a really interesting read! I’ve just started running training again for the London marathon next year, and although I’m doing a very basic walk/run programme just now, I already feel the benefit from getting outside and moving 🙂

    Like

    1. Thank you for commenting! 🙂 Speaking of the London Marathon it is something that occasionally pops into my head. You must need a lot of self discipline to do it! How many times have you ran it if you don’t mind me asking?

      Like

  2. This is a very interesting post. I do both cardiovascular and strength training and I was wonder which would help my mental health more. Personally I prefer cardio over strength training… Nothing feels better than working up a sweat on the elliptical until you feel better. It is a good outlet.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for the compliment! Indeed that seems to be the prevalent opinion from a lot of the people I know in my life. I mean I don’t think there is a clear cut answer to this question, but I would say that, on the whole I prefer cardiovascular activity for its therapeutic value. Although I tend to swim more than run 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I enjoyed reading your post about cardio vs. strength training. I enjoy both. However, as pointed out in the beginning of your post, I think it is important for someone to choose what is best for them. One of the things I would add to your post regarding doing cardio outside is the much added and scientifically proven benefit of nature’s natural Vitamin D from sunlight. Living in an area where we have substantially more cloudy and rainy days than sunny, I have to take a Vitamin D supplement to help offset my depression. Much can be said for getting outside, feeling the sunshine, smelling the plants and trees and feeling the wind. Happy exercising! PS Thank you for following my blog!

    Like

    1. Hi Julie. Thank you for reading it! Exactly – there really is no absolute answer to this debate as it currently stands.

      Also a very valid point regarding the Vitamin D – I will be sure to add it in don’t you worry! I find writing these kind of posts a bit tricky sometimes as there is a wealth of research I gathered but haven’t used as it would make it more overlong than it already is! I guess that’s just what comes with the territory when writing on a blogging platform.

      Also your blog is very intriguing all by itself so I was happy to follow it 🙂

      Like

  4. This is an awesome, well-written post! I do love how you casually wrote “gentle sprint”: I’m so unfit that those two words never occur together in my head.
    I do love the kind of training with an extra bit of intensity – I love feeling that exhaustion that you get after a really hard workout. Plus I’m one of those chronically grumpy people so it’s great to let out the frustration 😉
    Thank you for posting!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I can completely sympathise with being chronically grumpy haha. I am also with you on the intense training attitude – it’s why I box regularly and that is more tiring than weight training and running from my experience!

      Thanks for giving it a read – I hope you find something that works for you. Feel free to ask any me any more questions if you so wish 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  5. I´ve noticed a sharp distinction between yoga and resistance training (I try to do both). Resistance training helps me build myself (become stronger mentally), but it also pumps me up – it gets easier to really focus on things (sometimes, the negative). What yoga does for me is let go of that kind of energy.

    I prefer to do both in one day, when I can, and balance them out.
    Also thanks for the follow, I´m liking your content so will read along 🙂

    Like

  6. I do cardio, strength training, and yoga. Cardio, if I do moderate to intense effort, seems to energize me and give me that “runners high”. Lifting weights is like a chance for me to face challenges and frustrations head on by proving my strength against the weight. Some days I feel amaxing after lifting and other days I am frustrated and don’t feel like I’ve done enough. I usually feel better the following days as I get sore and recover because I feel stronger and more aware of my body. Yoga can be the same, depending on what kind I do. If I challenge myself it could get frustrating but if I do calm, slow stretching, I can really center myself. I try to combine the three so I can reap the benefits in all their different forms.

    Like

  7. People tend to naturally drift toward a certain type of exercise.They do what their good at, This is why flexible / hyper-mobile people tend to lean towards yoga / flexibility training and tighter / stronger people lean towards strength / resistance training. Ironically they should swop! the tighter people need the yoga and the yogis need the strength training. Its all about balance (yoga = yin Strength training = yang) with regards to mental well being its individual, Aerobic training elevates Cortisol levels (stress) for too long which is obviously no good for stressed people, strength training can bring confidence, I have witnessed this first hand from a lady suffering anxiety / mental health issues. In my opinion, do what makes you happy, and have balance.

    Like

    1. I completely agree with what you’re saying. I am guilty of too often leaning towards strength training as, like you say, I am one of those people who have a ‘tighter/stronger’ build. i am actually thinking of doing yoga myself.

      Thanks for your comment – it’s very enlightening!

      Liked by 1 person

  8. Great article. Very informative. I prefer cardio exercise and run 6kms 3 times a week. It does a world of good for my mental health.

    Like

  9. Great post! I’m not much of one for running or yoga, but I do enjoy strength training, walking and swimming! I really need to swim more, since I’m a real water baby. I find swimming both the most exhausting and relaxing activity out there. Whenever I get out of the water I always feel so good!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s